I loved Freespace 1 and 2 back in the day and still reinstall and play through every now and again, though most recently I had trouble getting into it again because for the past few years I've been heavily into IL2 1946. Going from that to FS2 was a bit of a letdown just in IL2 kills are so deliciously satisfying because there are so many possibilities in combat and so many things you have to get right --- mainly because of gravity and the difficulty of deflection shooting.
I've heard that these games are more towards the sim side of things which is definitely a good sign though.
Anyways, if anyone wants to share any thoughts on the games I'm all ears










